top of page


The Universalist Church builds the first church in Portageville.

The First Universalist Church in Portageville was organized on February 9,1841. Work was completed on the elegant Greek Revival meeting house the same year. The mid-nineteenth century was a period of rapid growth in the community. Families would travel long distances by ox cart and spend the whole day in Portageville, attending as many as three meetings a day in the Chapel.


A tornado damages much of the town but the church is spared.

A devastating tornado hit Portageville on July 4th, 1876, as residents were celebrating the centennial of the country. A detailed list of the damage to area buildings indicates (by omission) that the Universalist building did not suffer any damage.


The chandelier is fitted with oil lamps.

The brass chandelier that hung from the center of the room dated from the Victorian period and was originally fitted with oil lamps. The chandelier was stripped from the building just before we purchased the property.


Members struggle to keep the church open through
the great depression.

In 1933, a newspaper article written about the church gave a detailed account of the interior, which had remained unchanged for over 90 years. "There is no ante-room; one passes directly into the main part of the church and is confronted with the motto "God is Love. Love worketh no ill to his neighbor." The floors are slanted and the pews all have doors, fastened with wooden buttons. Oil lamps furnish the light."

We can see from the photographs that the chancel area was once painted with columns and latticework that appeared to be three dimensional. This was a popular technique employed by churches of the period throughout New England.

Another article, written in 1934, said that members were struggling to keep the building operating as a church. The organization was running on a small endowment, as Depression-era members could no longer support it. Soon after, the Universalist church closed its doors.


Neighbors celebrate the centennial of the building.

While the church was closed sometime after 1934, in 1941 a a neighboring Universalist Society held a special service commemorating the centennial of the building itself. The room was filled to near capacity. The last four members of the Portageville congregation (two of them in their 80's) were honored during the ceremony.


Community leader takes action to save the spire.

The church stood empty for another ten years. Like the town of Portageville itself, it was beginning to show its age. In 1950, Mrs. Elizabeth Beardsley, Genesee Falls historian, wrote to Wyoming County leaders to try to save the spire, which was in poor repair. The spire came down in a storm the following year.


The building is purchased and renovated by the
Seventh Day Adventists.

In 1951, the building was purchased by the Seventh Day Adventists. The building got a new coat of paint and was once again the gleaming white jewel at the gateway to the village. The Adventists added indoor plumbing and a new heating system. They also redecorated the interior to reflect their denomination and style of worship. Draperies and ornate chairs were placed on the chancel. The walls were covered with green wallpaper and maroon cushions were added to the box pews.


Wyoming County historian fights to preserve building. Local residents clean up grounds and
pay to repair broken windows.

In 1983, a diminishing congregation once again forced the church to close its doors. For three years the building stood empty, its paint peeling and its windows broken by vandals. Local residents, led by Mrs. Elizabeth Niederhauser campaigned to save it and Mrs. Niederhauser contributed her own money for replacement glass. John Wilson of the County Historian’s office tried to persuade the County Board of Supervisors to purchase the building and turn it into a County Historical Center.


The building is converted into a shop for secondhand furniture.

In 1986 the building was purchased and converted into a shop for secondhand furniture. The pews were disassembled and stored to make room for merchandise.


Inventory mounts.

The owners of the furniture business were much better at acquiring inventory than moving it. Even after the store closed in the mid-1990's, they continued to add more garage-sale ware, until the church, the basement, and the addition were filled to the brim. Platforms were added around the perimeter of the interior so that boxes could be stacked floor to ceiling. Over a period of twenty years, the usable furniture disappeared and the junk mounted. Still, the owners worked hard to keep the building secure and free from serious damage. And they were unwilling to sell the building to any buyer who might destroy it.


Restoration begins.

Timothy Smith, executive director of The Portageville Chapel, first noticed the church in 1989, and, for years, harbored the dream of restoring it as a retreat for organists. In 2006, he formed The Portageville Chapel, a not-for-profit organization, and purchased the property.

Restoration began early in 2007. At that time, overgrown trees all but obscured the front of the building. The adjacent property housed an abandoned trailer, rotted into the ground, and a lean-to that had once been a fishing cabin. The organization bought both properties and cleared away the debris. Together the building and adjacent land comprise just under an acre.

bottom of page